Please note: This page is best viewed using the Internet Explorer
6.0 or a later version.
Using Mobile Technology to Improve Visualization, Technical Communication,
and Analytical Skills of Engineering and Science
Students and Facilitate Student Learning
PI: Barry Hojjatie, Ph.D., P.E., Engineering and Physics Programs
In May 2006 an HP Technology for Teaching Grant
was awarded to the engineering program at Valdosta State University
to encourage transformation of
learning and teaching.
In July 2007 we received a second grant
from HP called Technology for Teaching Leadership Grant
to continue to employ the Tablet PC technology in classroom to transform learning/teaching in
engineering and Science courses through innovative uses of the technology.
Barry Hojjatie and a team
of faculty from multidisciplinary programs
[Professor Homa Hooshmand (Biology & Microbiology),
Dr. Mark Groszos (Structural & Physical Geology), Dr. Karl Soderholm (Dental Materials, Dental Clinics, University of Florida),
Professor Perry Baskin (Physics), Dr. Can Denizman (Geosciences, Landforms, Hydro-Geology),
and Ms. Beatriz Potter (Technology)]
are exploring the role of Mobile Technology in
improvement of student learning in engineering and science courses. The technology
is being used extensively in engineering graphics, 3-D visualization,
analysis of geometric relations and computations,
graphical communications, and better understanding of engineering mechanics courses.
The Tablet PC technology has created
opportunities for more interaction,
collaboration, and mobility.
Also, it has
generated more enthusiasm in students towards
learning and has enhanced the learning outcome in several engineering and science courses.
Rationale
One of the main challenges in teaching the engineering and science courses at VSU is
being able to handle a wide range of background and learning abilities
in students. Some of our students are quick in learning how to use computer tools and commands but
many are challenged in understanding geometric and angular relations/laws,
and logical reasoning associated with problem-solving fundamentals in physics and engineering.
Most of the freshman students in the engineering graphics course
need to be motivated to perform hand-drawing/analysis of geometric
shapes in 2-D and 3-D that is necessary for development of their
critical thinking skills. Because of these
issues, the rate of
retention of students in engineering is low.
We plan to transform the teaching/learning process
in our science and engineering courses to overcome these challenges.
Generally, our students
have shown more interest in engineering problem-solving and projects
when they are asked to work collaboratively on real-life problems
in the field, with individual attention given by the instructor.
Therefore, with the use of the Tablet PC technology we have
designed more project and field activities in
some of our courses, particularly in the lecture-base science and
engineering courses to encourage student learning through
collaborative interaction.
Implementation (pedagogy)
Before receiving the HP grant most of our science and
engineering courses were taught in the traditional
style in which the instructor lectured in the classroom using
a white board or PowerPoint and students took notes using pen and paper. Some of our
science courses are taught in large classes and a faculty member in our research team
who has taught more than 450 students each semester
has found the traditional style of teaching in these large classes to be less effective
because there is little opportunity for interaction with students.
In previous years in our Engineering Graphics For Design Course, students were using
Desk-top computers in the computer lab and it was not quite possible to perform
CAD based projects in the field. However, the course has been revised
to include more field activities using mobile technology.
During the past several semesters students in this course and in other engineering
and science
courses have shown a significantly more
interest in using
the Ink- writing capabilities of the Tablets for drawing/geometric analysis
as compared with the
traditional method of using pen and paper.
Every semester we are using the Tablet PC technology in more courses
in science and engineering to make teaching and learning
more interactive, hands-on, field-base, meaningful, and enjoyable for our students.
Based on the results obtained
by other educators
(Rogers and Cox),
in our large classes (e.g., geology, physics, and physical science courses) we are using
one Tablet PC for presentations of materials.
Because of the positive feedback and enthusiasm shown
by the students, we expect that in the long-term, the success and retention
rates in all programs, particularly in our engineering studies program
will increase significantly.
Implementation (technology)
We are developing a technology-based teaching methodology to enhance
student learning in engineering related courses such as engineering graphics,
physics, engineering mechanics, and other courses. In the engineering graphics course,
using the mobile technology,
we employ 15 different 3-D solid objects that we have constructed from wood blocks
to create hands on projects for students in CAD and solid modeling.
Students use the AutoCAD program to construct
2D/3D computer models
of these objects on Tablet PCs, then compare/discuss their drawings
and computational techniques
with each other and with the instructor in the lab/field to become
familiar with various problem-solving methods. Tutorial videos
have been developed on
Camtasia software
for students to learns
step-by-step methods of development of selected solid models.
The
Vision
classroom management program
is used to
monitor student progress in the CAD class. WEBCT VISTA is being
used extensively as a course management tool in the engineering and some
sciences classes.
In large classes (e.g., physics and geology courses), the stylus
of the Tablet PC is used by the instructor to place annotations
on slides during
PowerPoint presentations or to write/draw on the Tablet using the Windows Journal
to interact with students. In small classes/labs
a Tablet PC is used/shared by 1-3 students. Particularly, in our engineering mechanics
and thermodynamics courses students use the Windows Journal program
to draw free-body-diagrams, control volumes, and energy system on Tablet PCs
(some times superimposed on a
photograph of the enginnering structures and systems imported into
the Windows Journal). They are then able to share their
notes with each other in class or in the field.
Impact on Teaching
We are applying the Tablet PC technology in selected
large and small classes to encourage
collaborative interaction among students. Also, by designing more
field-base projects and activities, we
are making teaching and learning more meaningful and
enjoyable for both faculty
and students. We expect that because of the success of this project we will
have an increased rate of student success in many other engineering and science courses,
and will improve student retention in engineering.
A
survey
is being
distributed to students to evaluate the effectiveness of mobile technology in learning
fundamentals of each course. Another survey related to teaching was completed by
faculty.
Based on the initial survey, about 80% of
the students indicated that the effectiveness of Tablet PC in their learning
was high or very high, and they were motivated in using Tablet PC in classroom . Also, all 4 professors involved
on the Project have
indicated that the Tablet PC has made their teaching
more interactive and that they enjoy using it in their teaching.
Also, all students are being administered appropriate tests
and quizzes during a semester to measure their understanding
of fundamentals and problem solving techniques related to the courses.
The results are documented and compared with those from similar courses
from previous semesters in which no mobile technology was applied.
In physics and geology courses, the effectiveness of using one
Tablet PC in the classroom is being determined by comparing the student success
rates with those from previous semesters. In some courses (e.g., Engineering Graphics),
selected topics are presented to students using a traditional
approach and other topics with the same level of difficulty
are presented using Mobile Technology. Then the student grades
from each topic are compared.
The retention rate of students in engineering will be determined
using the student enrollment in upper level courses
(e.g., statics and dynamics), and number of students transferred to
Georgia Tech and other engineering schools
and compared with those from previous years.
"This grant not only has facilitated learning in engineering
and science courses through collaborative interaction and
field-based learning, but also has provided opportunities
for them to be actively involved in learning through undergraduate
research. Also, the Mobile Technology has made it possible
for our faculty to collaborate in interdisciplinary and
interdepartmental research projects related to science and pedagogy."
Dr. Louis H. Levy, Vice President
for Academic Affairs.
----------------------------------------------------------------
"The HP Technology for Teaching Grant and the HP Technology for
Teaching Leadership Grant are being used to integrate this cutting
edge instructional technology with traditional methods to improve
the effectiveness of teaching and learning in many areas in VSU
College of Arts and Sciences.
These grants have had a very positive impact on
our institution and the broader community."
Dr. Linda Calendrillo, Dean College of Arts and Sciences.
Impact on Student Learning
Several Years Ago (before implementation of
the HP-Technology project) -
Many classes in the engineering and science courses
were taught
inside and students and faculty were confined to the traditional classroom or laboratory
with traditional methods of teaching (using powerpoint slides and adding notes on the
white board). Note-taking and sketching were done by students using pen and paper.
This method of teaching allowed for little spontaneity or interaction,
and there were little or no experiments or projects
that could engage students in the field.
Also, students had difficulty in relating supplemental notes
written by the instructor on the white board with the drawing and text
materials shown on the screen. Our initial survey indicates that more than 75%
of our engineering and science students did not have any knowledge of or experience
with Tablet PCs.
One
Year Ago (the first year of the project) -
Only three of the VSU faculty members from engineering,
geology, and biology programs were experienced with Tablet PC.
Most other faculty members were teaching their courses using
either a white board or PowerPoint presentations from a desktop computer.
None of our students had the opportunity to borrow and use a Tablet PC
for the entire semester to learn about its advantages in note-taking
compared to the traditional method.
Today -
Sixteen of our colleagues have used Tablet PCs in their classrooms
on a continuous basis. Also, six students have had the opportunity
to use Tablet PCs in various courses for several weeks or the entire
semester. Several VSU students have performed geology field experiments
more than 200 miles away from our campus. Faculty members from various
fields of science, engineering, dental biomaterlas have used Tablet PC to
include annotation on their PowerPoint slides. Also, in place of the whiteboard,
they have employed Windows Journal and other tools that incorporate an electronic
ink option for classroom projection. Furthermore, these presentations
are made available to the students electronically using course management
programs such as WebCT. Based on student feedback, when the instructor makes
annotations directly on the projected information, the Tablet PC helps students to
better integrate the instructions comments with the projected content.
Because of the opportunity for interaction and active participation in
real-world experiments, students have shown more interest in learning the
fundamentals of problem-solving techniques. Comparison of student course
evaluations from all courses taught by the same instructor during the last
three years either with or without use of Tablet PC indicates greater student
satisfaction when the technology was employed by the instructor.
All upper level engineering students and many
science students have used
a Tablet PC in at least one of their classes.
In the engineering graphics for design course, teams of students can
work on collaborative field projects to perform measurements,
sketching, CAD drawing and design/modifications in the field using their
Tablet PCs. Because of opportunity for interaction and active participation
of students in real-world experiments, they have shown more interest in
learning the fundamentals of problem-solving techniques. In introductory
biology and geology courses, one Tablet PC has been used by the instructors
in large classes (~120 student/class). This method has been very effective in
generating student and instructor interest in lecture and learning and in increasing
lab efficiency. This improvement was due to
the fact that supplemental notes and drawings could be added
directly on each corresponding PowerPoint slide shown on the screen
that dramatically reduced any chance for confusion.
Many field experiments are performed in laboratory courses
with Tablet PCs including:
1. A geology field experiment conducted in a cemetery near VSU campus
to evaluate erosion characteristics of various rocks. They analyzed the data,
plotted the results in graphical forms, and compared their findings in the field.
2. A second geology field experiment conducted in the north Georgia
mountains ~250 miles away from campus using Tablet PCs.
3. A biology lab exercise that demanded students to go to the field for
sample-collection was modified (due to inclement weather). Instead students
used their Tablet PCs to search the web for simulated field samples and virtual
data-acquisition of plants and animals found in different ecosystems to classify
study and tally the samples. In groups of four, students used the electronic
ink option of Tablet PCs to enter data, make tables and draw graphs.
They also saved their work and submitted to WebCT.
Results
-
Shown in the figures 1-5
are some of the results/examples from the application of
Mobile Technology in our courses during he Fall 2006 and Spring 2007 semesters.
It is evident that the number of students receiving a grade of "A" or "B"
was increased significantly and in general, the number of "C"s and "D"s decreased
when Tablet PCs were used in the classroom (Figs. 1, 3, & 4). Also, the course
enrollment in statics and dynamics increased when Tablet PC was used in
teaching and learning (Fig. 2). Note that the results shown in Figs. 3 & 4 correspond
to the application of one Tablet PC in classroom which confirm the findings by
Rogers and Cox
that using one Tablet PC in classroom can have a significant
impact in student learning.
Fig. 1- Comparison of student grades in the Engineering
Graphics for Design course when two sets of problems (with the same level
of difficulty) were given to the students. Teaching/learning in problem set #1
was without the use of mobile techonology, while in set #2 Tablet PC's
were used in classroom.
Fig. 2- Comparison of the course enrollments in
statics an dynamics in recent semesters
during which the Mobile Technology was used with
those from previous semesters (without the use of Mobile Technology).
Fig. 3- Comparison of student grades in a geology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Fig. 4- Comparison of student grades in a general biology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Fig. 5- Two examples about the
applications of Windows Journal in enginering statics and dynamics courses.
1. Drawing the free-body-diagram (FBD) of
an enginnering structure on its picture (Figure on the left). Instead of
drawing the FBD in a separate diagram (as done conventionally), this method
is proposed to give better underestanting of real-life
problems to engineering studensts. 2. An example of a
Tutorial work-sheet prepared on Windows Journal for our statics students
(Figure on the right).
Fig. 6- Comparison of student grades in a general biology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Fig. 7- Comparison of student grades in a general biology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Fig. 8- Comparison of student grades in a general biology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Fig. 9- Comparison of student grades in a general biology course
for two methods of teaching (traditional vs. technology-enhanced).
Note that in the technology-enhanced method, only one Tablet
PC was used by the instructor.
Summary of the Results
-
Based on analyses of data obtained from student/faculty surveys, students test performance
in several courses during our studies since the Fall semester of 2007, we have observed
that the technology-enhanced
teaching and learning has made a very positive
impact in student learning.
One Year From Now -
We expect to obtain more positive results (higher grades, increased rate of
retention, and improved course evaluation) in our
enginering and sciences courses. We will
include new courses (e.g., several physics courses),
perform more controlled experimentations with
Mobile Technology in classroom, and conduct statistical analysis of
the data for comparison
of teaching/learning methods with or without the use of
Mobile Technology. We anticipate that we will continue to obtain
very positive results from
our new approuach and will confirm our preliminary finding that
application of Mobile Technology will result in:
A significant
increase in student interest in class participation.
A significant
improvement in student grades in all courses.
An improved student evaluation in all courses, thus, will have
a very positive impact in faculty attitute toward teaching.
An
increase in student retention rate in
the VSU engineering studies program.
Figs. 10 and 11- VSU engineering students
working on statics and dynamics problems.
Using the Windows Journal program and the
eletronic ink option of Tablet PCs
students perform 3D vector analysis, draw Free-Body-Diagrams,
fill the blank
areas of partially solved problems,
and discuss
their methods of solutions with each other and with the instructor
Fig. 12 (Top Left):A VSU egineering student using a Tablet PC in a CAD project in the field.
Fig. 13 (Top Right): The 3-D CAD drawing corresponding to the field project in previous figure.
Fig. 14 (bottom Left): A VSU egineering student using a Tablet PC in a another CAD project in the field.
Fig. 15 (bottom Right): The 3-D CAD drawing corresponding to the second field project.
Fig. 16: Solution of a sample problem in dynamics on a Tablet PC.
Fig. 17: A tutorial dynamics problem developed on Tablet PC.
Fig. 18: A summary of some physics equations using Tablet PC to upload on WebCT for teaching and learning.
Fig. 19: A graphical solution of a dynamics problem on Tablet PC.
Quick Facts
Dept.:
Engineering Studies program, at Physics Astronomy and Geosciences Dept.
Courses Impacted:
Engineering Graphics for Design (ENGR 2500),
Statics (ENGR 2010), Dynamics (ENGR 3210), Thermodynamics (ENGR/PHYS 4310),
Computational Physics (PHYS 3820),
Introduction to Biology (BIOL 1030), Introductory Physics I & II
(PHYS 1111 & PHYS 1112), & Geology (GEOL 1010).
# Students Impacted:
Approximately 1200 students in 2007 & 2008 (In large classes e.g., BIOL 1030 and GEOL 1010,
one Tablet PC is used by the instructor, in engineering, physics and laboratory
courses a Tablet PC is shared by 1-3 students).
Fig. 20 (Top Left): Soil temperature measurement using Tablet PC and the LabView Data Acquisition
Program in a thermodynamics field project.
Fig. 21 (Top Right): VSU geology students using thier Tablet PCs
at a north Georgia mountain (250 miles from VSU campus).
Fig. 22 (Middle Left): Tablet PC being used in a geology field experiment at a cemetery
near VSU (evaluating erosion characteristics of rocks).
Fig. 23 (Middle Right): Students in an Engineering Graphics
field project redesigning a walkway at VSU.
Fig. 24 (Bottom left): Two views of the VSU walkway
and its sketch on the Windows Journal.
Fig. 25 (Bottom Right): Drawing of the walkway by a
VSU student on a Tablet PC.
Video #1- A Video clip from WCTV (a TV station serving Northern Florida and Southern Georgia)
about the second HP grant awarded to VSU in 2007. The clip also shows Allan Bishop (a VSU
engineering student) discussing his field project
using the AutoCAD program on a Tablet PC.
II. Presentations
1. Barry Hojjatie, Homa Hooshmand, Beatriz Potter and Joe Newton:
"Using Tablet PCs to Improve Teaching and Learning",
Online Lifeline Conference 2007, VSU, February 16, 2007.
http://www.valdosta.edu/distance/onlinelifeline
2. Barry Hojjatie and Homa Hooshmand:
"Application Of Tablet PC Technology in Teaching Engineering and Science Courses",
GA Academy OF SCIENCE, March 31, 2007.
http://www.gaacademy.org
3. Matthew Stokley & Alan Gavel (students), and Barry Hojjatie (Advisor):
"Measurement and Analysis of Soil Temperature Using Tablet PC Technology",
2007 Undergraduate Research Symposium, April 12, 2007.
http://www.valdosta.edu/cur/programs
4. Kyle Lovan & Miguel Pena (students), and Barry Hojjatie (Advisor):
"Development of Tutorial Programs for Engineering Mechanics Using Tablet PC and Camtasia",
2007 Undergraduate Research Symposium, April 12, 2007.
http://www.valdosta.edu/cur/programs
5. Barry Hojjatie and Kyle Lovan (student):
"Tablet PC as a Too to Improve Effectiveness in Teaching/Learning
Mechanics and Basic Engineering Courses",
21st Canadian Congress on Applied Mechanics (CANCAM 2007), Mini-Symposia on
Engineering Education, Toronto, Canada, June 3-7, 2007.
http://www.ryerson.ca/cancam07/Minisymp.htm
7. Hojjatie, B., Gavel, A., Stokley, M., and Brevik, E.:
“MEASUREMENT AND ANALYSIS OF SOIL TEMPERATURE USING
TABLET PC TECHNOLOGY”, Annual Meeting of Florida and Georgia
Academy of Science Meeting, Jacksonville, FL, March 14-15, 2008.
http://www.floridaacademyofsciences.org
8. Hooshmand, H., Groszos, M., and Hojjatie, B.:
“EFFECTIVENESS OF TABLET PC IN TEACHING AND LEARNING SCIENCE
COURSES: A TWO-YEAR STUDY” Annual Meeting of Florida and Georgia Academy of
Science Meeting, Jacksonville, FL, March 14-15, 2008.
http://www.floridaacademyofsciences.org
9. Rose, J. (Student), and Hojjatie, B. (Advisor): “USING VIDEO AND
SIMULATION FOR THE IMPROVEMENT OF ENGINEERING EDUCATION”, Undergraduate Research Symposium, April 10-11, 2008.
http://www.valdosta.edu/cur/programs
10. Hojjatie, B., Leader, L., Hooshmand, H., and Söderholm, K.:
“HOW CAN USE OF TABLET PCS IN CLASSROOM/CLINIC FACILITATE LEARNING?”,
International Association of Dental Research Conference, Toronto, Canada, July 2-5, 2008.
http://www.iadr.com/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=3297
III. References
1. Dave Berque, Jane Prey, and Robert Reed (Editors): "The Impact of Tablet PCs
and Pen-based Technology on Education", Purdue University Press, (2006).
2. Terry Derting, and Dr. Ricky Cox:
"A Campus-Wide Initiative to Develop,
Deploy, and Assess Five Models of
Technology-Enhanced Teaching and Learning",
http://www.cfkeep.org/html/snapshot.php
3. Rogers, J. W. and Cox, J. R. HP Online Speaker Series, May 12, 2006.
Talk entitled "The One-Tablet Classroom: Methods, Student Attitudes and
Learning Gains."
http://www.uwex.edu/ics/stream/uwc-rock/hp/
Other Video Clips
Note: If screen is blank click ">" twice to activate/play.
____________________________________
Video #2- VSU Undergraduate Research Symposium (April 2007), A Student
Project Using Tablet PC and Camtasia for Development of a
Tutorial in 3-D solid modeling.
____________________________________
Video #3- a. Tablet PC in a Geology Field Experiment at a Cemetery near VSU,
b. Soil Temperature Measurement Using Tablet PC and Labview
Interfaced to 3 Thermocouples
(A Student Field Project at the Thermodynamics Course).
____________________________________
Video #4- Tablet PC in a Structural Geology Field Experiment at the Georgia Mountain about
250 miles North of VSU.
____________________________________
Video #5- Testimonial video from David, a VSU engineering student.
____________________________________
Video #6- Testimonial video from Jamasia a VSU engineering student (in English, Spanish, and
French).
____________________________________
Video #7- Testimonial videos from Miguel, Stephanie, and Sal, students from VSU.
____________________________________
Video #8- Testimonial videos from Shane and Brooks, engineering students from VSU.
____________________________________
Video #9- Testimonial videos from Chad and Chris, engineering students from VSU.
Acknowledgements
Financial support of the Hewlett Packard (HP) Technology
for Teaching Grant is Gratefully Acknowledged.
Additional funding was provided by the VSU Office of Grants
and Contracts, and the Center for Applied Research
(instrumentation and conference presentations).
Mr. Philip Bishop from the VSU
media services provided editorial support
in preparation of the video clips.